This just doesn’t feel right. It gives the impression that a judge who deals Samsung’s number one rival a huge PR blow, in a way that I found very extreme and unjustified, will be generously rewarded. For that reason alone, I think both Samsung and Sir Robin Jacob should not have done this. What would people say if Judge Lucy Koh, a few months after denying Apple a permanent injunction against Samsung, returned to private practice and was hired as an “expert” by Samsung in a German litigation with Ericsson? I guess there are written or at least unwritten rules in the United States that would prevent this from happening in the first place. In the UK it appears to be above board and accepted.
Nie wątpię, że Florian ma rację mówiąc, że to nie ma nic wspólnego z faktem, że sędzia wydał taki a nie inny wyrok, ale takie rzeczy nie powinny nigdy mieć miejsca. To wręcz absolutnie niedopuszczalne i słusznie przyrównuje całość do Lucy Koh.